Both candidates target Windows, but they have different purchase and feature boundaries. PDFgear’s free position makes it a possible starting point for routine edits, while PDF-XChange Editor is a paid perpetual edition with a separate Plus upgrade. Do not buy the ordinary Editor expecting the form-authoring entitlement documented for Plus. Likewise, the Windows PDFgear record does not inherit a capability from the Mac product. Check existing-text editing, scanned content and form creation as distinct tasks. A same-file trial should inspect saved output and any edition restrictions. An advertised redaction control is not a verified permanent-removal result.
Vendor sources and our tests are labelled separately. Independent tests that have not been run are not implied.
Vendor documentation is shown below. Independent tests are pending. Totals show known charges in each product’s currency; no currency conversion, tax or future price increase is assumed. List charges exclude volume discounts.
PD
PDFgear
Windows
PlatformWindows
Purchase basisFreePrice checked: 13 Sept 2026
Known 1-year cost · 1 person$0.00Tax excluded. Free edition; paid extras are excluded.
Edit existing textAvailable · official sourceOfficial source · 13 Sept 2026Advertised by the vendor; no independent task test recorded.
Read scanned text (OCR)Available · official sourceOfficial source · 13 Sept 2026Advertised by the vendor; no independent task test recorded.
Create fillable formsSource reviewed · not establishedOfficial source · 13 Sept 2026Reviewed source does not establish this exact task for this edition.
Fill existing formsNot established
Annotate & signAvailable · official sourceOfficial source · 13 Sept 2026Advertised by the vendor; no independent task test recorded.
Merge & organize pagesAvailable · official sourceOfficial source · 13 Sept 2026Advertised by the vendor; no independent task test recorded.
Permanently redact textSource reviewed · not establishedOfficial source · 13 Sept 2026Reviewed source does not establish this exact task for this edition.
Offline core taskNot verified
OCR conversion does not establish scanned-page editing fidelity. Form creation and permanent redaction were not established for this Windows edition.
Known 1-year cost · 1 person$62.00Tax excluded. Single-user perpetual license with one year of maintenance included. Optional maintenance extensions and taxes are extra; future versions require valid maintenance.
Edit existing textAvailable · official sourceOfficial source · 12 Sept 2026Edits existing PDF text; document fidelity has not been tested.
Read scanned text (OCR)Available · official sourceOfficial source · 12 Sept 2026Standard OCR is included; Enhanced OCR requires Editor Plus.
Create fillable formsNot supportedOfficial source · 12 Sept 2026Creating and editing fillable form fields requires Editor Plus. Filling existing forms is a different task.
Fill existing formsNot established
Annotate & signAvailable · official sourceOfficial source · 12 Sept 2026Annotation and signature tools are listed for this edition.
Merge & organize pagesAvailable · official sourceOfficial source · 12 Sept 2026Page insertion and document organization are documented.
Permanently redact textTool documented · outcome test neededOfficial source · 12 Sept 2026Redaction and sanitization tools are advertised. Permanent removal still needs an extraction test on the exact installed version.
Offline core taskLocal core task documented · task test pending
Form creation and Enhanced OCR require Editor Plus. Manual offline activation needs a connected second device for the license exchange.