Home US Defiant elderly doctor tells judge he ‘did nothing wrong’ in helping woman commit suicide

Defiant elderly doctor tells judge he ‘did nothing wrong’ in helping woman commit suicide

0 comments
Stephen P. Miller, 85, has been sentenced to five years' probation after admitting to the involuntary manslaughter of Doreen Brodhead in a New York motel room last November.

A disgraced former doctor who helped a middle-aged woman commit suicide due to chronic “neck and back pain” has escaped jail time after pleading guilty to manslaughter.

Stephen P Miller, 85, travelled from his home in Arizona to upstate New York to help Doreen Brodhead get the canister of poison gas she used to end her life in a motel room in Kingston last November.

He was arrested in February when investigators discovered he had been communicating with the 59-year-old woman for six months before her death, after she contacted him through the right-to-die advocacy group Choice and Dignity.

Her attorney, Jeffrey Lichtman, said the former pediatrician tried to talk Brodhead out of killing herself before agreeing to help her and only charged her for her expenses to help her die.

“Technically, he broke the law, we accept that,” Lichtman told reporters. “But with the understanding that, morally, Stephen Miller did nothing wrong.”

Stephen P. Miller, 85, has been sentenced to five years’ probation after admitting to the involuntary manslaughter of Doreen Brodhead in a New York motel room last November.

Staff found the 59-year-old man's body in a bed at a hotel in Kingston, New York.

Staff found the 59-year-old man’s body in a bed at a hotel in Kingston, New York.

Super 8 motel staff found Brodhead’s body in a bed in his room on Nov. 9, along with a note and a canister of nitrogen gas.

Surveillance footage revealed that Miller had picked her up from her nearby apartment the day before leaving to buy gasoline.

Survey

Should physician-assisted suicide be available where you live?

  • Yeah 8710 votes
  • No 6676 votes
  • I’m not sure 1464 votes

He took her to the hotel and was seen carrying the tank to his room, then leaving to buy a key after the tank developed a problem with its regulator.

An hour after returning, he drove back to Albany and took a flight back to his home in Tucson.

Miller told investigators that Brodhead hesitated about the plan as she sat with him in the motel room and told him she would miss her mother.

Aiding or causing another person to commit suicide is considered a felony in New York under state law.

Miller was charged with murder and two counts of assault.

Friends said Brodhead attributed her chronic pain to her early career as a dental hygienist and said she had undergone six unsuccessful surgeries in an attempt to find relief.

According to the advocacy group Death with Dignity, physician-assisted dying is legal in ten states, including Maine, New Jersey, Vermont, New Mexico, Montana, Colorado, Oregon, Washington, California, Hawaii and Washington, DC.

Lawmakers in Oregon and Vermont have made deadly drugs easier to access by allowing out-of-state patients to travel and end their lives.

Attorney Jeffrey Lichtman said his client has no plans to assist in any more suicides.

Attorney Jeffrey Lichtman said his client has no plans to assist in any more suicides.

But none of those states allow assisted suicide for people who are not terminally ill.

Miller, who received his medical degree in 1964, was jailed for three years and had his medical license revoked in 2006 after being convicted of a $1 million tax fraud.

His lawyer said he had helped many other people end their lives since leaving prison and had provided “very little technical assistance” to Brodhead in his final hours.

But he insisted that his elderly client would not do it again.

“That part of his life is over,” he added.

Miller faced a possible 25-year prison sentence if convicted on all charges, but reached a deal with prosecutors who dropped assault charges in exchange for admitting to manslaughter.

“Are you pleading guilty because, in fact, you are guilty of second-degree murder?” Judge Bryan Rounds asked him during the brief hearing Tuesday in Ulster County Court.

“By your definition, yes,” Miller replied.

The court accepted his request and sentenced him to five years probation.

Brodhead’s mother, Mary, 91, defended the doctor when contacted by the New York Times earlier this year.

“It was her choice,” she told the outlet outside her Kingston home.

“He didn’t force her to do it.”

State laws on assisted suicide in the United States

California It passed the End of Life Option Act in 2015, and a revised bill in 2016 shortened the waiting period for approval from 15 days to 48 hours.

Colorado Voters approved Proposition 106 in 2016, legalizing assisted dying for terminally ill patients, by 65 percent.

D.C. She passed the Death with Dignity Act in 2016, which went into effect a year later, despite Republican efforts to block the bill.

Hawaii It has legally permitted assisted dying since 2019, based on models from Oregon and Washington state.

Maine It is the ninth jurisdiction to legalize assisted suicide in the country after Maine’s Death with Dignity Act was enacted in 2019.

Mountain Aid in dying was legalized through a state Supreme Court decision in Baxter v. Montana in 2009, but it has not been determined whether the state constitution protects it.

New Jersey It is the seventh state to legalize assisted suicide after Governor Phil Murphy signed the Aid in Dying for the Terminally Ill Act in 2019.

New Mexico The legislature passed the Elizabeth Whitefield End-of-Life Options Act in 2021 to allow terminally ill patients with six months to live to request lethal medication.

Oregon It became the first “suicide tourism” destination in 2022 by declaring it unconstitutional to deny assisted suicide to people from other states who wish to travel to Oregon to end their lives.

Vermont The legislature passed the Patient Choice and Control at the End of Life Act in 2013 and the governor signed it into law the same year.

Washington Voters approved the Death with Dignity Act in November 2008 by a margin of 58% to 42%.

You may also like