Some of the most popular income mutual funds have failed to recover from the coronavirus crash – and experts think it may be time to sell them.
Merchants Investment Trust is down 39 percent this year and Murray International is down 25 percent. Still, the FTSE 100 is down just 20 percent after rebounding from its low of 4,994 to 6,032 by the end of last week.
The question for many investors who have money in these gigantic funds is whether they should continue to pay the income they are paying now or free it up for a rival with better prospects.
Some of the most popular income mutual funds have failed to bounce back from the coronavirus crash
For example, traders still pay a very healthy return of 7.39 percent – or £ 7.39 per year for every £ 100 in the fund. Murray International’s revenue is now 5.63 percent.
While these payouts are made to look more generous – you’re getting a bigger percentage from a smaller pot – they shouldn’t be sniffed at.
Still, Ben Yearsley, director of Shore Financial Planning, points out that longer-term capital growth is vital to driving higher payouts. In other words, if money continues to struggle, the income paid out may not grow or even be cut.
“You need your capital to grow to grow your income over time,” Yearsley says. “So you would seriously look at alternatives for your income if your assets are going badly.”
Chris Salih, investment analyst at FundCalibre, adds, “Whether you should keep trusts for income only if they underperform in terms of capital growth is a very subjective question and depends a lot on the type of investor you are.
Ideally, you’d want both. But as you retire or approach, it’s understandable that you’ll want to prioritize income – especially since dividends are currently cut left, right, and center – provided your initial investment isn’t greatly eroded by capital losses. ‘
Merchants and Murray International are favorites among income seekers. Murray International, managed by Aberdeen Standard Investments, is a £ 1.4 billion trust that has been around for over 100 years – meaning it has weathered its fair share of catastrophes. But it has recently underperformed markets such as the FTSE World and MSCI World indices.
It is essential that your capital continues to grow over time
So far, confidence has lost nearly 24 percent this year compared to a largely flat performance of the FTSE All World index. In the past year, the trust has lost 15 percent, against a nearly 4 percent increase for the index.
Laura Suter, personal finance analyst at AJ Bell, said: “Murray International has been hit harder than some of its peers this year because of its ‘value’ investment approach.
“This means it invests in companies that it believes have been unfairly priced by the market and are ready for recovery.”
Unfortunately for investors, many of those stocks were among those hardest hit in the market’s declines earlier this year – Mexican airport operator Grupo Aeroportuario del Sureste, for example. In addition, says Suter, the trust didn’t have much exposure to the technology stocks that have driven much of the global recovery.
Murray International has recently underperformed markets such as the FTSE World and MSCI World indices
The fund has exited the UK equity markets and lowered its allocation to the UK to a 40-year low, and instead is betting its fortunes on Asia and emerging markets, which are recovering faster than in other parts of the world. As these are some of the areas most affected by the pandemic right now, investors will likely have to be patient and endure more volatility in the coming months. ‘
But it’s not all doom and gloom, Suter adds. “Income seekers will be comforted that the trust has said it intends to maintain its dividend growth policy and that the trust has sufficient reserves to cover a year’s worth of dividends if necessary.”
Investment trust Merchants, a £ 700 million fund that invests in UK equities, had some sort of purple growth path early this year.
However, Suter of AJ Bell says, “ The trust has a high debt ratio (borrowing money to invest in the market), which means that any rises and falls in the value of the underlying assets are amplified. In general, gearing has been shown to increase returns on investment funds in the long term, but add to volatility in the short term – meaning investors should be prepared for a wilder ride on the road. ‘
The good news is that Merchants has committed to at least keep the dividend this year. Suter thinks it will likely plunge into its cash reserves this year rather than cut its payout.
Ben Yearsley thinks that is a bad sign. “By diving into cash reserves, confidence can keep dividends artificially higher in the short term,” he says. ‘But Merchants, for example, has Imperial Brands, Shell and many financial companies among the greatest interests. Those kinds of things have not recovered at all – and in some cases have even continued to decline. ‘
Merchants is down 39 percent this year, but has pledged to keep the dividend
FundCalibre’s Salih says both the Merchants Trust and the Murray International Trust focus on value investing – a type of investment strategy that has been out of fashion for a number of years. “Quantitative easing (or money printing) and low interest rates have fueled the growth strategy of investing,” he says.
In growth investments, a fund manager will pick up stocks that are on the rise, rather than stocks that can recover from a rough time.
Salih added, “ With the recent stock market selloff, central banks around the world have introduced even more quantitative easing in the markets, while interest rates have fallen even further, making the background even more challenging for value investing as these companies often more in debt. ‘
Unlike Merchants and Murray International, Finsbury Growth and Income Trust has fallen in value only 8 percent since the start of the year, but at 1.99 percent, returns are lower than both.
It may be better to ride any bumps in the road
Scottish Mortgage, the largest investment firm, started the year at £ 5.86, but has now skyrocketed to £ 9.03 after a small Covid dip thanks to technology holdings in Tesla, Amazon, Tencent and Alibaba. That means investors have seen £ 1,000 turned into £ 1,536. However, the trust offers a dividend yield of only 0.36 percent.
Yearsley recommends Finsbury Growth and Income, which he says has “a lower initial income but with better growth prospects.”
Other alternatives that Salih denounces at FundCalibre include Murray Income, which continues to deliver strong 4.52 percent yield. “The manager is very experienced and his long track record is still good,” he adds.
However, he warns against making hasty decisions. He points out that the coronavirus has and will continue to have a tremendous detrimental effect on the economy and the wider market – so false moves driven by short-term price movements can be costly.
Suter agrees: “Clearly, in times of market volatility and downturns, investors tempted to sell for better opportunities elsewhere should be careful not to lock in a loss that may be difficult to recover from.
“If the fund has indicated that the capital growth cut is temporary and they are still finding income opportunities, it may be better for investors to hold on tight and bridge the bump in the road.”
Bruce Stout, manager of Murray International, says, “We will not be chasing short-term returns. Instead, we will continue to focus on financially strong companies in regions of the world where long-term growth prospects remain superior. ‘
Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links. If you click on it, we may earn a small commission. That helps us to fund This Is Money and keep it free. We do not write articles to promote products. We do not allow a commercial relationship to affect our editorial independence.