Take a fresh look at your lifestyle.

Sonos’ recycle mode is being closed by an e-waste expert who claims that ‘reuse is always better’

A software institution that permanently disables Sonos smart speakers so that their parts can be recycled has received criticism from an e-waste employee who claims that ‘reuse is always better’.

Once activated, the ‘recycle mode’ setting starts counting down before all personal data is deleted from the device and the device is blacklisted on the Sonos servers.

It is intended for use in the California-based Trade Up program, which encourages customers to take their old equipment to an e-waste center or return it to Sonos for recycling in exchange for a credit for future purchases.

However, Devin Wilson, who writes on Twitter, has declared the program a program that is “environmentally unfriendly” and “damages e-waste recyclers.”

Scroll down for video

The 'recycle mode' function that makes Sonos smart speakers non-functional has been criticized by an e-waste employee who claims that 'reuse is always better'

The ‘recycle mode’ function that makes Sonos smart speakers non-functional has been criticized by an e-waste employee who claims that ‘reuse is always better’

WHAT SONOS SPEAKERS CAN BE ‘TRADED’?

The following devices are eligible for the upgrade program:

Play: 5 (Gen. 1) (Released in 2009)

To connect (Released in 2007)

Connect: Amp (Released in 2004)

According to the Sonos website, the “Trade Up” program is “the simple, sustainable way to upgrade your Sonos system.”

‘When you recycle an eligible Sonos product, you choose to permanently deactivate it. The deactivation occurs 21 days after you have chosen to recycle the Sonos product. The 21-day countdown cannot be canceled, “it continues.

As part of the Trade Up program, users receive a 30 percent discount on each new Sonos product.

“We think it is the right decision to make recycling a condition for this offer,” says the luxury speaker manufacturer.

The use of a locally certified e-recycling facility is the most environmentally-friendly disposal method […] “It’s more environmentally friendly than sending it to Sonos,” they add.

In a recycling center, the loudspeakers can be split into their component parts and the materials can be recycled – certainly a better alternative to the environment than sending the devices to landfill.

Wilson, however, thinks it would be better if the swapped-in speakers could be refurbished and resold – a process that would be less energy-intensive, but would also allow e-waste centers to make more profit on such devices.

Recycling used electronics is rarely a fully effective process – because there are usually some components that cannot be reused or recycled.

“Saving working and valuable electronics for renovation and reuse is the most environmentally friendly way of doing things, and the reason we can still exist as a company,” Wilson said Gizmodo.

“I decided to talk about this independently of my employer, because [Sonos’] hypocrisy and unique bad actions with this program make me angry. “

Wilson – who works for Renew Computers in San Rafael, California – added that he “sees himself as an environmentally conscious person who hates working electronics being scrapped.”

E-waste handler Devin Wilson writes on Twitter and has declared the Trade Up program a program that is 'environmentally unfriendly' and 'damages e-waste recyclers'

E-waste handler Devin Wilson writes on Twitter and has declared the Trade Up program a program that is 'environmentally unfriendly' and 'damages e-waste recyclers'

E-waste handler Devin Wilson writes on Twitter and has declared the Trade Up program a program that is ‘environmentally unfriendly’ and ‘damages e-waste recyclers’

Wilson went to Twitter after a customer dropped off five Sonos Play: 5 speakers in his e-waste center.

“They are worth $ 250 each, and they are in good condition. They can easily be reused, “he wrote.

“Unfortunately, the person who recycled them has placed them in recycle mode.”

“This is the most environmentally friendly abuse and waste of perfect hardware that I have seen at a recycler in five years.”

“We could have sold these and made sure they were reused, as we do with all the working electronics that we can. Now we have to delete them. “

“This is the only time that I have explicitly shown a company its own hardware in the name of” sustainability “and” encouraging recycling. ”

“Saving working and valuable electronics for renovation and reuse is the most environmentally friendly way of doing things,” Wilson told Gizmodo

“We take our responsibility for the environment seriously and strive to constantly improve our sustainability practices,” said a Sonos spokesperson The edge.

“The reality is that these older products do not have the processing power and memory to support modern Sonos experiences. Over time, technology will advance in ways that these products cannot be placed.

‘The Trade Up program is an affordable path for these owners to upgrade.

“We felt that the most responsible action was not to re-introduce [the old products] to new customers, who may not have the context as products more than 10 years old, and who may not be able to deliver the Sonos experience they had expected. “

.