Nintendo games everyone owned and now worth serious money

Advertiser Disclosure: At Slickdeals, we work hard to find the best deals. Some of the products in our articles are from partners who may reimburse us, but this does not change our opinion.

How much Nintendo games you traded in without thinking during a trip to GameStop? Unfortunately, there’s a decent chance you could have made a few hundred bucks if you had made a different decision that day.

Many of the most expensive games on the resale market today come from lesser-known Nintendo properties. While that’s not exactly shocking, it’s a bit surprising how many once-everyday games are now worth tons of used money.

In some cases, this is due to Nintendo’s love of small discs and cartridges – both of which are more difficult to mass-produce than Blu-rays or DVDs. With fewer copies on the market, games that have not been re-released become particularly attractive to collectors.

To give you a better idea of ​​what? not to skip (or let go), we’ve put together a list of the most expensive Nintendo games available today. Don’t feel too bad, there’s no way you could have known that copy of it NCAA 2K3 would be worth so much more than $3 in store credit.

Rare, expensive games that everyone used to have

Remark: Due to the ever-changing trends and price fluctuations in the resale market, we have calculated the current average price of each game using recent sales data and current prices for copies that are new (sealed), complete (used and in good condition) and loose (disc- nothing but). We’ve left out lists that seem suspiciously high or low, along with collectibles like empty boxes, art, and manuals.

Pikmin 2

  • Platform: Nintendo GameCube

  • List price: $19.99

  • Current average price: $75

The saga of Pikmin 2 provides valuable insight into why Nintendo products tend to become scarce and expensive as they are. Simply put, the company underestimated the game’s appeal and didn’t release nearly as many copies as North American players wanted, at a remarkably reasonable launch price of $20.

The game was mind-bogglingly rare already in 2008, even when it was easy to find plenty of other GameCube games in stores – often at a discount, given the recent release of the Nintendo Wii.

2. Pokemon Colosseum

  • Platform: Nintendo GameCube

  • List price: $49.99

  • Current average price: $96

To make Pokemon Colosseum a true RPG was a risky gamble for Nintendo, as it broke the mold of the series’ earlier strategy game format. Today, it is an invaluable resource for acquiring powerful Legendary Pokémon such as Ho-Oh, Suicune, and Entei in other titles.

The game is still expensive today due to Nintendo’s fairly small-scale release, despite Colosseum’s value in the competitive world of Pokémon breeding.

3. Doom II

  • Platform: Game Boy Advance

  • List price: $19.99

  • Current average price: $107

Programmers are always pushing the boundaries of which electronic devices can run mischief, an MS-DOS game released in 1993. Although Doom II came out just a year later and offers an equally robust number of available ports, game collectors and mischief Enthusiasts still hunt for the rarest and most expensive official port, the 2002 Game Boy Advance Edition.

4. Fire Emblem Radiant Dawn

fire emblem characters are some of the most loved fighters in Super Smash Bros. today, but the original game series was a sleeper hit for Nintendo. When Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance saw moderate turnover in 2005Nintendo has scaled back the release for the sequel, Radiant Dawn.

Future releases sparked a wave of Fire Emblems popularity, pushing the already sparse resale selections to a huge new high.

5. Pokemon Platinum

It’s common knowledge that the third game in every Pokémon generation acts as a “complete” edition that typically costs more than the previous two. Whether this is justified remains a hot topic among fans, but this high price is best explained by the game’s perceived “deluxe” value mixed with Nintendo’s constant production of new games and consoles (making recent games quickly go to “no more”. printed’ status).

6. SNES Classic

At some point, it seems that Nintendo’s business model is based on artificial scarcity. According to the bad rollout of the NES Classic in 2016, Nintendo was going to do the exact same thing with the release of the SNES Classic.

Plagued by shortages, scalpers took to town for the nostalgic despair and desire to relive a simpler time. GameStop even joined in the fun by selling strangely expensive “bundles” of unrelated merchandise from games that were unrelated to the SNES Classic’s catalog.

7. Pokemon Gale of Darkness

  • Platform: Nintendo GameCube

  • List price: $29.99

  • Current average price: $177

Despite the unique mechanics for training shadow Pokemon, this Pokemon Colosseum sequel didn’t sell as well during its original release. The game’s rarity and ability to interact with Game Boy Advance cartridges have elevated it to cult status today, making it the most expensive Pokémon game for GameCube.

8. Castlevania Aria of Sorrow

  • Platform: Game Boy Advance

  • List price: $49.95

  • Current average price: $263

Again, collectors are paying an arm and a leg because of Nintendo’s poor underestimation of how many people are going crazy over their games. Castlevania Aria of Sorrow saw decent reception when it was released in 2003 and today it is considered one of the best titles in the series. Its value as a game and collectible has kept the price well above the suggested retail price for over 10 years.

9. Dokapon Trip

Niche titles from smaller Japanese game studios typically get smaller releases compared to major Nintendo titles from the same era. Dokapon trip turned out to be an extreme example. Although it has a single player mode, this game is best known for its array of multiplayer RPG board games and party mechanics. All players must have their own deck of cards, which is a difficult and expensive undertaking given the limited number of copies available.

10. NCAA 2k3

  • Platform: Nintendo GameCube

  • List price: $24.99

  • Current average price: $296

Sports games with annual releases are notorious for their low resale value, so the extreme rarity of NCAA Basketball 2K3 may seem surprising. Ironically, it’s so rare because it’s old very bad on the GameCube. This led to Sega’s decision to completely remove the 2K series from the platform, leaving 2K3s legacy as a coveted collectible.

11. Shepherd’s Crossing 2

On the face, Shepherd’s Crossing 2 looks like a dime harvest moon knock off. Poor marketing has left this game in the shadows for years, despite the growing genre of soothing everyday games on portable consoles. Due to the low sales volume, it almost completely disappeared until a small but dedicated fan base got a boost Shepherd crossing 2‘s popularity, which led to a frenzied stampede for the few copies in circulation.

12. Barbie Groom and Glamor Pups

Barbie: Groom and Glam Pups is one of the most expensive 3DS games available today, but not because it flew off the shelves. On the contrary, the small run in Canada went so badly that the game was quickly pulled from the shelves and never released in the United States. Logically, this means that everyone will pay top money to care for these rare and glamorous pups.

Next one

Our editors strive to ensure that the information in this article is correct as of the date published, but please note that listings are subject to change. We recommend that you check all terms and conditions of each product before signing up.