Categories: Australia

Dan and Catherine Andrews car crash with Ryan Meuleman in Blairgowrie Mornington Peninsula Victoria

A former Crown prosecutor has referred to as for a recent investigation into the collision between a automobile occupied by the Victorian Premier Dan Andrews and the bicycle ridden by 15-year-old Ryan Meuleman that left {the teenager} combating for his life. 

James Bowen, former Victorian Queen’s Counsel,  stated lately launched proof urged Daniel and Catherine Andrews’ account of the 2013 accident would possibly defy the ‘legal guidelines of physics’.

He additionally believes the investigation by Victoria Police was such a ‘scandal’ the case have to be investigated by one other pressure. 

The accident, which occurred on Victoria’s Mornington Peninsula on January 7 of 2013, has resurfaced to canine Mr Andrews on the marketing campaign path as he seeks a 3rd time period for his Labor authorities on the November 26 election.   

Victorian Premier Dan Andrews (proper) and his spouse Catherine (left) had been concerned in a severe automobile crash in 2013 that left a 15-year-old bicycle owner critically injured

Mr Meuleman, who’s now 24, launched a grenade into Mr Andrews’ election possibilities when he informed the Herald Solar his reminiscence of the accident differed sharply from the accounts of the Premier and his spouse, who was driving the automobile. 

Mr Meuleman additionally stated a lawyer from Labor-linked legislation agency Slater & Gordon informed him he wanted to ‘maintain quiet’ in regards to the accident or he wouldn’t obtain $80,000 in compensation from the Transport Accident Fee when he turned 18.

Underneath strain from attorneys for the Mueleman household, police on Sunday launched beforehand unseen pictures taken on the scene of the accident which Mr Bowen says ‘contradict the account of the collision’ by Mr Andrews.

Mr Andrews had refused to remark, saying all queries in regards to the accident must be directed to police. 

Each the Premier and Victoria Police have refused to reply additional questions put to them by Every day Mail Australia in regards to the case.

Ryan Meuleman was left on the street screaming in agony after the collision and needed to airlifted to a Melbourne hospital the place docs stored him alive with steady blood transfusions and had been pressured to take away 90 per cent of this spleen

THE CRASH

Mr Meuleman informed the Herald Solar he remembered biking slowly throughout Ridley Avenue, close to the city of Blairgowie, about 1pm when a automobile got here ‘dashing’ across the nook ‘out of nowhere’ and struck him.

The accident left Mr Meuleman in agony with a punctured lung, damaged ribs, and inner bleeding.

He was airlifted to a hospital in Melbourne and docs needed to pump litres of blood and marrow into him due to a ruptured spleen. 

Surgeons had been finally pressured to take away 90 per cent of the injured organ. 

Mr Meuleman, who’s now 24, has come ahead virtually 10 years later to dispute the Premier’s account of what occurred

ANDREWS’ DIFFERING ACCOUNT OF THE CRASH 

Mr Andrews insists Mr Meuleman T-boned the Ford Territory, which was offered to Mr Andrews due to his function as Opposition chief on the time. 

‘The bicycle owner was travelling at velocity and hit our automobile at an ideal proper angle very closely,’ Mr Andrews informed police in his official assertion. 

‘I need to make it clear – the bicycle owner hit our car.’ 

The primary witness to the scene was Jane Crittenden, who stated she virtually drove into the again of the Andrews automobile. 

It isn’t identified whether or not police took a witness assertion from Ms Crittenden. 

The brand new photos simply launched – grainy photocopies of the police originals – present the SUV’s windscreen smashed from a heavy impression on the motive force’s aspect

New police photos have been revealed beneath the Freedom of Info Act that present for the primary time the harm to the Ford Territory

THE POLICE INVESTIGATION   

Mr Bowen informed Every day Mail Australia the crash was solely attended by ‘two very junior police’, which he referred to as a ‘severe breach of regular police process for investigating severe visitors collisions’. 

He stated regular process would have been for the street to have been closed off and for police specialists from the Accident Investigation Unit to research, none of which occurred. 

The 2 officers attending the crash additionally did not breath take a look at Catherine Andrews, who testified she was driving, with Mr Andrews within the passenger seat and the couple’s three younger kids within the again.

The police photos additionally present harm to the entrance nook bodywork forward of the entrance tyre which the Meulemans insist helps their declare the care Ms Andrews drove into Ryan, now 24

BREATH TEST FAILURE AND ‘APOLOGY’ 

The failure to breath take a look at led to an investigation of the case by Victoria’s anti-corruption watchdog in 2017 after police regularly refused FOI requests by the media and the Meuleman household to launch the complete case recordsdata. 

After the Unbiased Broad-based Anti-corruption Fee (IBAC) cleared the police actions, the then Victorian Police Commissioner Graham Ashton blamed the missed breath take a look at on miscommunication.

‘It was a busy scene, and in that busyness one thought the opposite had performed [the breath test],’ Mr Ashton stated.

‘There wasn’t any suggestion that they had intentionally performed something improper.’

Mr Andrews stated one of many officers even apologised for not doing the breath take a look at.

‘She (the officer) stated, “I am actually sorry that we did not breath-test you. We should always have”,’ he stated. 

Retired Victorian Crown prosecutor James Bowen (pictured) says the investigation of the crash by Victorian Police is a ‘scandal’

ANDREWS LEAVES THE SCENE WITH WIFE AND CHILDREN 

As Mr Meuleman was nonetheless mendacity on the bottom screaming, Mr Andrews was allowed to drive his automobile, with its closely cracked windscreen, to the household’s close by vacation home to drop off his traumatised kids and spouse.

Mr Bowen stated that ought to by no means have occurred. 

‘The lately disclosed police pictures now present that driving the Ford Territory away from the collision scene with badly shattered windscreen could have been an offence towards Victorian visitors legislation,’ he stated. 

Mr Bowen stated regular process was to impound a car concerned in a serious crash and have it examined by police collision specialists, which was not performed.

‘This severe failure makes reconstructing the circumstances of the collision far harder,’ he stated. 

Daniel Andrews gave police a proper assertion in regards to the crash a month after it occurred

WHAT HAPPENED AFTER THE CRASH  

Police didn’t publicly report the accident and Mr Meuleman’s father Peter was not informed who had been concerned.

Peter Meuleman solely realized who was within the Ford Territory when an insurance coverage declare was lodged beneath the identify of Catherine Kesik, which was Ms Andrews’ maiden identify. 

Related Post

The crash was solely made public 9 days after it occurred when Peter Meuleman approached the Herald Solar to say Mr Andrews and his spouse had not contacted him. 

When requested in 2017 why he had not been in touch with the household, Mr Andrews cited authorized causes.

‘I keep and Victoria Police are supportive of the choice I made (to not contact the household any extra), that was the suitable factor to do,’ Mr Andrews stated.

‘The very last thing I used to be ever going to do was to try to talk to a witness, a minor, earlier than the police had performed so.’

Ryan Meuleman claims no assertion was ever taken from him and this has been supported by the paperwork to date launched by police. 

The police report dominated out any fees towards the motive force or the bicycle owner and located it was the results of ‘Bounce into Automobile Path, Out from Behind Object’ 

MYSTERIOUS LAWYER

Ryan Meuleman claimed he was informed by a lawyer from Slater & Gordon that to get compensation for the accident he needed to maintain quiet and never contest the compensation cost. 

Slater & Gordon is a agency that specialises in industrial relations work for unions and former workers embody future Labor prime minister Julia Gillard and future Greens chief Adam Bandt. 

‘I principally needed to maintain my mouth shut,’ Ryan informed the Herald Solar in regards to the ‘deal’ supplied to him. 

‘It type of scared me into signing immediately and simply agreeing with it.’ 

Mr Meuleman’s mom Sonia Johnstone supported her son’s claims. 

The Meuleman household has continued to request all paperwork associated to the case however have been repeatedly met by police refusals. 

Catherine Adams stresses she was the motive force on the time of the incident and stated she had been going slowly as she needed to cease on the junction to permit a learner driver to cross

ACCIDENT DESCRIPTION 

Mr Andrews has refused to say something extra in regards to the accident because the story resurfaced on November 4th, regularly stating he lined the matter on the time and after the IBAC investigation.

Nonetheless, he did describe the crash intimately throughout a press convention in 2017. 

‘It is not like he is (Mr Meuleman) within the roadway and we stumble upon him, it isn’t like he is getting into the roadway and we stumble upon him and the brakes are utilized and we attempt to cease, no,’ Mr Andrews stated.

‘The roadway was clear. We turned to speed up to then transfer down the street. He crashed with such, such pressure into the aspect of the automobile.

‘He got here from the correct, proper on our eyeline for those who like, hit round that mirror on the aspect and the wheel after which was put up into the windscreen and excessive of the automobile.’ 

PHOTOS  AND PHYSICAL EVIDENCE

The pictures launched by police present a car with a closely dented entrance proper bumper bar and smashed driver’s aspect window. 

Former Victorian police commissioner Graham Ashton blamed the failure to breath take a look at Catherine Andrews on the ‘busyness’ of the crash website

Mr Bowen, who retired as a crown prosecutor in 1993, stated the pictures had been of ‘appalling high quality’ however ‘contradict’ the account of the collision by Mr Andrews and his spouse.

‘MAY DEFY LAWS OF PHYSICS’ 

The smashed windscreen of Mr Andrews’ automobile ‘clearly urged a head-on collision with the bicycle rider’, Mr Bowen stated, relatively than a side-on T-bone as claimed.

‘If the collision occurred as Daniel Andrews claims by the bicycle owner hanging the Andrews car on the motive force’s aspect “at an ideal proper angle” then the legal guidelines of dynamics could come into play.

‘The police {photograph}… would point out that the physique of Ryan Meuleman would very possible have been thrown throughout the bonnet earlier than touchdown on the street on the opposite aspect of the Andrews car. 

‘This didn’t occur because it ought to have if the Daniel Andrews’ assertion to police is appropriate.

‘The physique of Ryan Meuleman clearly struck the windscreen and shattered it. 

‘If the Daniel Andrews model of the collision could be believed, Ryan’s physique in flight must change course sharply to the left and strike the windscreen. 

‘This may increasingly defy each widespread sense and the legal guidelines of dynamics.’

A report on the accident by a visitors engineer employed by the Meuleman household asserts it’s ‘extremely unlikely that the bicycle owner was travelling at excessive velocity’ because the statements type Mr Andrews and his spouse point out. 

Mr Bowen (pictured) believes that the photographic proof contradicts the claims made by Dan and Catherine Andrews about how the crash occurred

POLICE STONEWALLING  

Every day Mail Australia requested police 9 questions in regards to the case, together with why no assertion was taken from Ryan Meuleman, why Mr Andrews was allowed to go away the scene along with his household and his spouse and why the Ford Territory was not impounded.  The premier’s workplace was additionally requested why Catherine Andrews was not breath examined. 

Police despatched the next response: ‘For privateness causes we don’t focus on people.’

When requested in regards to the pictures of the smashed Ford Territory on Tuesday, Mr Andrews directed reporters to Victoria Police. 

When this was put to Victoria Police they issued a two-line assertion.

‘Victoria Police performed a radical investigation into the incident,’ the assertion stated.

‘Because the investigation has been finalised, Victoria Police has no additional remark to make.’ 

Questions had been additionally despatched to Mr Andrews media workforce and so they issued the next assertion.

‘All of those questions have been addressed at quite a few press conferences,’ the spokesperson stated. 

‘We now have nothing additional so as to add.’ 

The crash story has thrown a spanner into the re-election marketing campaign of Dan Andrews, seen right here with spouse Cath within the Melbourne seaside suburb of Williamstown

‘A SCANDAL’

Mr Bowen stated there have been ‘so many appalling failures of regular police investigation’.

He referred to as the investigation a severe scandal for ‘which the Victoria Police must be held accountable’.

The case ‘deserves additional investigation however not by Victoria Police who’ve already failed the sufferer,’ Mr Bowen stated.

He referred to as for investigators from one other state to reopen the case. 

Jacky

Recent Posts

4 Best Video Doorbell Cameras (2022). Smart, Wireless and a Word about Eufy and Ring

Wired Vs. Battery Powered: Smart doorbells require more power than traditional doorbells. You may need…

1 min ago

Here are the Facts You Need to Know When Betting in Quebec

Even with the recent approval across Canada of betting on a single sporting event, Quebec…

1 min ago

Gombe State: Primary health services for the most vulnerable

Gombe, 1 December, 2022 - The big idea about Universal Healthcare Coverage (UHC) is that…

2 mins ago

Sharon Chan launches skincare line

An enthusiastic entrepreneur, Sharon Chan (陳敏之), 43,  is slowly reducing her screen time. Appearing in…

2 mins ago

Mets engage in constant talks ahead of the Winter Meetings

47 minutes agoMLB.com is keeping track of all the latest trade and free-agent rumors involving…

3 mins ago

After revealing her 12-year-old daughter’s strict beauty guidelines, Mum Eliza Nixon splits the opinions

32-year-old mother of four is divided over her strict 'beauty rules' for her 12-year-old daughterA…

9 mins ago